Listen to a convo comparing the Guardian and Daily Wire on Trump’s talk and deal to close the border. Much more info is below as well.
Days after President-elect Donald Trump threatened to impose a 25% tariff on goods entering the U.S. from Mexico and Canada, Trump claimed that Pres. Claudia Sheinbaum of Mexico had agreed to stop migration through her country and close the Mexican border. But Sheinbaum suggested that is not the case. @weijia reports.
Days after President-elect Donald Trump threatened to impose a 25% tariff on goods entering the U.S. from Mexico and Canada, Trump claimed that Pres. Claudia Sheinbaum of Mexico had agreed to stop migration through her country and close the Mexican border. But Sheinbaum suggested… pic.twitter.com/peu4DOztg0
— CBS Evening News (@CBSEveningNews) November 29, 2024
Briefing Doc: Trump and Sheinbaum Discuss Border Security
Date: November 28, 2024
Subject: Conflicting reports emerge from a phone call between US President-elect Donald Trump and Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum regarding border security and tariffs.
Sources:
- The Guardian (Left-leaning)
- The Daily Wire (Right-leaning)
Key Themes:
- Border Security and Immigration: Trump claims Sheinbaum agreed to halt migration through Mexico to the US, effectively closing the southern border. Sheinbaum, however, denies agreeing to shut down the border, highlighting Mexico’s existing efforts to address migration.
- Fentanyl Crisis: Both leaders acknowledged the fentanyl crisis and discussed collaborative efforts to combat drug trafficking and addiction.
- Potential Tariffs: Trump previously threatened tariffs against Mexico and Canada, citing their inaction on immigration and drug trafficking. Sheinbaum initially suggested retaliatory tariffs, but later stated that their conversation reassured her a tariff war was unlikely.
Important Facts and Quotes:
- Trump’s Claim: “She has agreed to stop Migration through Mexico, and into the United States, effectively closing our Southern Border” – Source: Daily Wire
- Sheinbaum’s Denial: “I can assure you, I guarantee you, that we never – additionally, we would be incapable of doing so – proposed that we would close the border in the north [of Mexico], or in the south of the United States.” – Source: The Guardian
- Sheinbaum on Collaboration: “We will always defend our sovereignty. Mexico is a free, independent, sovereign country – and that is above everything else.” – Source: The Guardian
Analysis:
The conflicting reports on the outcome of the call highlight the differing narratives emerging from the US and Mexico. While Trump emphasizes Sheinbaum’s alleged agreement to halt migration, Sheinbaum focuses on Mexico’s existing efforts and the potential for collaboration.
The discrepancy likely stems from differing interpretations of the conversation and political maneuvering. Sheinbaum may be downplaying any agreement to avoid domestic backlash, while Trump may be exaggerating to appease his base.
Further Developments to Watch:
- Concrete actions taken by both governments regarding border security and fentanyl trafficking.
- Implementation or withdrawal of threatened tariffs.
- Future communication and potential meetings between Trump and Sheinbaum.
Conclusion:
While both leaders expressed a desire to address shared challenges, the specific details of their agreement remain unclear. Continued monitoring of actions and statements from both sides is crucial to understanding the future of US-Mexico relations under the new Trump administration.
